Welcome to Incremental Social! Learn more about this project here!
Check out lemmyverse to find more communities to join from here!

Anticorp ,

And second, you do realize saying that separating Jewish people from zionists is like "splitting hairs" is anti-semetic right?

That wasn't my opinion. What I read in their charter that you shared is that they associate all of Israel with Zionism. So their statement that they don't want the destruction of the Jews, only the destruction of Zionism and Israel, is semantics. If they state that all of Israel is Zionist, and Israel is the home of the Jewish people, then they are still advocating the destruction of the Jewish people. That's what I meant by "splitting hairs".

What do you propose? The Jewish people have just as much right to exist as every other people. They have a long and storied history in that region, and eons long conflict with Palestine. This isn't their first time occupying that region. So how is Palestine's claim to the entire region of Israel more legitimate than Israel's claim? Just because they have been there without Israel more recently? I do agree that Israel should pull out of Palestine, but I don't agree that that includes the entire territory of their whole nation.

The Iranian Islamic revolution of 1979 overthrowing the US-backed monarchy was also deeply religious, and resulted in a drastically improved quality of life for everyone in the nation.

I strongly disagree. Women lost the majority of their rights because of that revolution, and live heavily oppressed now. People lost a lot of their liberty, and they're subject to religious law, which is imposed upon them. My best friend's wife is from Iran. Her parents still live in Iran. She has a very large family, all of whom I am close with, and not a single one of them views the Islamic State of Iran as an improvement to the conditions in the country prior to the revolution. Granted, their opinions aren't necessarily representative of every person in Iran, but they're as close as I can personally get to that situation. I trust their judgement and intellect, so I tend to believe the things they tell me.

We're getting further away from the actual topic of discussion though, which was that Biden is funding and supporting genocide. I think I've already made my position on that clear, so I won't burden you with it again.

I appreciate you taking the time to share your perspective with me, and discuss this in a civilized manner.

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • memes@lemmy.ml
  • random
  • incremental_games
  • meta
  • All magazines