Right but I think that was their point though no? That, for safety reasons, they didn't make it to orbit. Seems like a pretty cut and dry "no" they didn't make it to orbit just like that person said. And the reason was that they didn't know if it would make it. Which kind of supports their point.
I'm not going to claim to know enough either way (besides Elon Musk being an idiot), but they don't seem wrong there.
It seems like you guys are mad that it didn't make orbit and get defensive when people point it out.