Welcome to Incremental Social! Learn more about this project here!
Check out lemmyverse to find more communities to join from here!

davel ,
@davel@lemmy.ml avatar

Apple will now require a court order or search warrant to give push notification data to law enforcement in a shift from the previous practice of accepting a subpoena to hand over data.

A subpeana is a court order so that’s clear as mud.

MagneticFusion ,

once again apple marketing making it SEEM like they care about your privacy

HeartyBeast ,

So. What do you suggest they in practice?

ReversalHatchery ,

Not lying that they are improving the privacy of users would be a good start

HeartyBeast ,

But what should they specifically do in this case to improve the situation - got any actual suggestions?

ReversalHatchery ,

No, I don't have any suggestion for how should Apple circumvent laws. But if they can't improve on it, they shouldn't lie that they did so.

HeartyBeast ,

Hang on - what exactly did they lie about?

hemko ,

They're lying about many things, such as their respect for privacy, right to repair, sustainability, what else. Oh they've lied about use of slave labor if I recall correctly

ReversalHatchery ,

Sorry for the delay. In this case they were lying that they have improved their process regarding handling such orders, implying that they will now only comply for fewer orders that they can't (yet) deny.

HeartyBeast ,

Previously they required a subpoena, now they require a court order. So what was the lie?

ReversalHatchery ,

A subpoena is a court order. Nothing has changed and they market that as an improvement.

An order issued under the authority of a court, commanding a person to appear in court on a particular date, usually to give testimony in a legal case. A writ requiring someone to appear

https://www.wordnik.com/words/subpoena

A subpoena is a kind of court order. Specifically it is an order to a particular person to appear and testify at a particular time and place. In many but not all cases, the order also requires that person to bring specified records or documents along. That is known as a subpoena duces tecum. In some cases this is used to, order the production of documents without any accompanying testimony.

[...]

Ther are many other court orders, such as an injunction which is generally an order not to do something. Different jurisdictions may use different terms for orders with similar effects. The exact name and exact effect of a given order will vary with the jurisdiction, which is not stated in the question at the moment. The needed process to obtain a court order will also vary. Without a jurisdiction, a more specific answer cannot be given.

https://law.stackexchange.com/questions/59478/what-is-the-difference-between-a-subpoena-and-a-court-order

If anything, they have even broadened the scope of documents they now accept for information disclosure requests.

HeartyBeast ,

From the orginal linked reporting, it appears that previously Apple would accept a subpoena subpoena issued by police departments and law enforcement agencies with no judicial oversight. Under the new policy there has to be a court order or a search warrant, both of which have to be approved by a judge.

This feels like a tightening to me. https://techcrunch.com/2023/12/13/apple-push-notifications-government-warrant/

  • All
  • Subscribed
  • Moderated
  • Favorites
  • privacy@lemmy.ml
  • incremental_games
  • meta
  • All magazines